My Al Capone Museum | home
MY AL CAPONE MUSEUM | The Capone Trash Bin | FAQ's | Links | Mario Gomes | Al Capone's Personal Silver Locket | Al Capone's Personal Telephone | Al Capone's Personal Dress Shirt | Al Capone's Personal Straw Boater? | Al Capone Framed Signature | Al Capone's light fixtures | Al Capone's Silver Tray | Ralph Capone's Personal Silver Pin and Dice | Hymie Weiss Personal Prayer Book | John D. Torrio's Personal items | Louis "Two Gun" Alterie signed photo | SVD Massacre bullet fragments | Interesting items retrieved from Al Capone's Lexington office suite | Alton Hotel Relics | Al Capone Wax Figure | 7244 Prairie Avenue | 93 Palm Avenue | 93 Palm Avenue Part 2 | 93 Palm Avenue Part 3 | 93 Palm Avenue Part 4 | New 93 Palm Avenue home | New Palm Avenue home Part 2 | Artifacts from 93 Palm Avenue | The Capone era Cicero, Illinois | The Harvard Inn | The Hawthorne Hotel | The Metropole Hotel | The Four Deuces (2222 South Wabash) | Al Capone's Bathroom Tile From The Lexington Hotel | Inside The Lexington Hotel | Geraldo's Capone Vault Grand Opening | Lexington's Destruction | X Marks the Spot magazine | Capone Magazines and Booklets | Capone Videos | Capone Books | Knick Knacks | Capone's Chicago | Chicago photos | Capone Documents | Capone Photographs | Capone Photographs 2 | Capone Photographs 3 | My History channel Shoot | Gravesites | Gravesites 2 | Al Capone Speaks On Film! | FDR and Al Capone's Cadillac; Truth or Myth? | Al Capone Goes To Atlantic City | Al Capone and Friends: | Al Capone Goes to Cuba | The Real Al Capone Quotes | Capone at the Ballpark | Al Capone's Death and Funeral | The St. Valentine's Day Massacre | The Massacre Pt.2 | Massacre Victim's Stats. | Massacre News blurbs | Some Theories on the Valentine Massacre | Discounted Valentine Massacre theories | Valentine Killers? | The St. Valentine's Day Massacre Wall bricks | The St. Valentine Massacre guns today | The Infamous St. Valentine's Day Massacre forensic evidence | The Adonis Social Club Incident | When, Where and How did they die? | Gangster facts and side stories | The Obituaries | Gangster talk | Gangster Fashion | Gangster Molls | William Hale Thompson | Gangland Armourers | The Chicago Typewriter | Gangster Hitspots | Mae Capone | Louise Rolfe | Alberto Anselmi and Giovanni Scalise | Frank Parker | William Niemoth | Jack Guzik | Samuel "Golf bag"Hunt | Jake Lingle | Frankie Yale | Samoots Ammatuna | Jack Zuta | Leo Vincent Brothers | Edward David Vogel | John D. Torrio | Joe E. Lewis | Rocco DeGrazia | Machine Gun Jack McGurn | Willie Heeney | James "Fur" Sammons | Jack "Three fingered" White | George "Red" Barker | Anthony "Tough Tony" Capezio | Frank Nitti | Dean Charles O'Banion | Samuel Morton | George Clarence Moran | Hymie Weiss | Vincent "The Schemer" Drucci | Fred "Killer" Burke | Fred Goetz | Joe Aiello | Edward "Spike" O'Donnell | The Genna brothers | Angelo La Mantia | Frank Rio | Ragtime Joe Howard | Hinky Dink and Bathouse John | Sol Van Praag | Theodore "The Greek" Anton | Joseph P. Bergl | Daniel "Danny" Stanton | Edward Tancl | Louis & Elliott Wisbrod | Eliot Ness | Al Capone's tax trial and downfall | Al in Jail | Thomas Prior | Robert Gallo as Al Capone | Mr. Joe Walters | Gangster articles | Newspapers of the day | Newspapers part Two | Newspapers Part Three | Newspapers Part Four | The Green Mill | Colosimo's | Alcatraz | Alcatraz Part 2 | Al Capone goes to Baltimore | Gangster sites today | Gangster Sites part 2 | Dead Gangsters | Origins of the Scars | Al Capone Myths | Collecting Al Capone? | The truth about Al Capone's signature | Al Capone and other Gangster related books | In Memoriam | Contact Me | Capone/ Gangster Collectibles for Sale
The truth about Al Capone's signature
I'm always amazed and shocked to see the abundance of fake Al Capone signatures out on auction and really feel sorry for the people who unknowingly believe these to be real. I wasn't planning on doing a section on this subject, but after seeing these poor people plunking their hard earned $$$$ I decided to give autograph hunters a Al Capone 101 course on what to look for in buying big Al's John Hancock. As for authentic signatures, many just buy these items and just resell them at exhorbitant rip off prices. While Al's signature is definitely worth money ,some shady dealers blow it way out the ballpark ,making it inaccessible to the average collector. There are honest dealers out there and one example is listed below.
From the Estate of a Philadelphia Banker. 1923 check with payment made out to Alphonse Capone. Interesting little story since Al made frequent trips to New York at that time, helping take care of his family's affairs for the big move into Chicago.
He had made his first appearance in Chicago mid to late 1920 and lived in an apartment with his brother Ralph. He came into possession of the Chicago South Prarie home on August 8,1923.
The rest of the Capone family was in New York. Father Gabriele had passed away and was interred in New York and later reburied in Chicago's Mt Olivet.
The front of the check is signed by Arnold Behrer, who was the son of Arnold Behrer Sr. (47 Cliff street) He owned the Arnold Behrer and Sons plumbing supply company in Jamaica, New York. ( Behrer Sr. had died in July of 1919 at age 76).
Arnold Behrer Jr. also had some properties including a nightclub called La Casino Cabaret at 160th street near Jamaica Ave.
Could Capone have been paid for working in plumbing supplies?(Lead pipes)? Could have he supplied muscle in the clubs?
The possiblilties are endless.
The back of the check signed by Al Capone. This was before he was to become king of Chicago gangland.The check was made by the Brown, Lent and Pett company at 90 Williams street New York. They later moved to 70 Washington street.
The Check was issued from the Bank of Manhattan company situated at Fulton and Union hall streets (Jamaica).
Al went to the Corn Exchange bank in Queens at 25th and Roosevelt Avenue to cash it on the 23rd of June 1923. During this period, Al had cashed several of these checks (possibly three or more) with variying amounts from the same payer. This could have been payoff to Torrio or money owed to Al for previous work.
My special thanks to Mr. Scott Gurten for making it possible to show the world this magnificent piece of Capone memorabilia. Scott is a Philadephia based autograph and memorabilia dealer.
Below are other examples of Al's authentic signature taken from various official documents to give an indication of his handwriting styles and their variances.
He always signed his name Alphonse Capone for all police, court or prison documents and signed his name Al Capone for the public.
Al Capone endorsed check. Circa 1923.
Official documents with Al's name can fetch up to anywhere from $2,500 to $10,000
Al always has certain distinctive features about his handwriting.Notice the a in the Capone.It always has a tail in the front. If you find an autograph for sale without it don't bother!!
Remember, if it matches exactly as one of the above, then you have a fake on your hands. No one person can replicate their own signature exactly!! Autopens and tracing can. It has to look the same, with variances to be authentic. Also important to note, just because an autograph dealer or auctioneer is reputable and knows his sports and Hollywood memorabilia, doesn't mean he knows squat about Al Capone. I did a little test with a Capone relative's authentic Al signature, and to my amazement the reputable dealer said it wasn't real (despite my many years in this subject and the unrefuted relative provenance). Just goes to show. I've also seen many fakes sold off for thousands!!!
To add more discouraging news, it has been shown that unscrupulous people also fake the certificates of authenticity.
I don't know squat about sports or Hollywood signatures, but Al is something I'm familiar with.
To avoid being taken here are some easy guidelines to follow.
1) Does it come with provenance??
Provenance is very important. Dates must jive with how the signature was obtained. (Saying Al signed an autograph in 1934 would make it impossible as he was at Alcatraz).
2) If the signature is up on auction with no reserve for $500, then run away as far as you can because it's probably a fake. Why would someone in their right mind let go of an authentic signature worth thousands for a couple of hundred dollars??
Stay away from Capone signatures from overseas!!!!!!
Many unscrupulous people will get an old newspaper and find a section with no writing and imitate Al's signature. Remember at that time Al signed with a fountain pen and most of the time it was signed with one that he had on him at all times. Ballpoint pens didn't exist, so that's another indication.
Now, not all dealers or auctions are bad. Many of them are honest and on the up and up ,so do be afraid to invest in a piece of history. Count on spending a little more to get something official. (Documents,bank checks, police records with official stamps etc..).
Just go at it prepared.
First Posted March 2006